If your website’s rankings suddenly drop and you start seeing a surge in suspicious traffic or backlinks, it’s natural to worry—especially about something as serious as negative SEO.
A recent discussion on Reddit’s r/SEO brought fresh attention to this topic, with one user reporting a sharp ranking drop after noticing a flood of spammy backlinks.
The question is: was it an attack or just a coincidence? And more importantly—how should you respond?
Let’s break it down.
❓ What Is Negative SEO?
Negative SEO refers to malicious strategies used to harm a website’s search engine rankings. These tactics are often deployed by competitors or bad actors and can include:
- Creating thousands of spammy or irrelevant backlinks
- Linking from adult or unrelated domains
- Duplicating your content across low-quality websites
- Hacking your site to insert spam pages or links
The goal? To make your site appear untrustworthy to Google and trigger a drop in rankings.
⚠️ Real-Life Case: Spammy Links + Ranking Crash
In the Reddit post, the user described a massive increase in spammy backlinks coming from low-authority websites—and shortly after, a noticeable drop in keyword rankings.
Others in the thread chimed in with similar stories. Some suspected sabotage, while others believed the issue was more likely tied to a Google algorithm update or existing SEO flaws.
This raises a critical point: not all ranking drops are caused by negative SEO—but it’s worth investigating if the timing feels suspicious.
🧠 What Google Says About Negative SEO
Google’s official stance? Their systems are smart enough to identify and ignore spammy backlinks that don’t reflect your SEO efforts.
Google Search Advocate John Mueller has said that most low-quality backlinks are automatically discounted and won’t negatively impact your rankings. Similarly, Google’s Gary Illyes claimed that out of the many negative SEO cases reviewed, none were confirmed to be real.
This doesn’t mean negative SEO never works—but it’s extremely rare, and Google’s algorithm is typically good at handling it.
🛠️ Should You Use Google’s Disavow Tool?
Google offers a tool called the Disavow Tool, which lets you tell them to ignore certain backlinks pointing to your site. However, using it comes with a warning.
Google strongly recommends only using this tool if:
- You know the links are unnatural or spammy
- You built them yourself in the past (e.g., via black-hat SEO)
- You’ve tried and failed to get them removed manually
Overusing or incorrectly using the disavow file can actually hurt your SEO performance. If you’re unsure, it’s best to consult with an SEO expert.
🔒 How to Protect Your Website from Negative SEO
Even though Google is good at ignoring spammy links, you should still take steps to safeguard your site:
1. Audit Your Backlink Profile Regularly
Use tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or Google Search Console to monitor new links. Watch for sudden spikes in low-quality backlinks.
2. Set Up Google Search Console Alerts
Get notified if Google detects manual actions, crawl issues, or security problems on your site.
3. Secure Your Website
Update your CMS, plugins, and passwords regularly. Use security tools to prevent hacks or spam page injections.
4. Track Keyword Movements
Monitoring your rankings can help detect early signs of a problem—especially if certain keywords suddenly drop without reason.
5. Be Cautious with the Disavow Tool
Only use it when you’re 100% sure the links are hurting your site and can’t be removed manually.
🧩 Ranking Drops Aren’t Always Attacks
While it’s tempting to blame competitors or negative SEO, most ranking drops happen because of:
- Google algorithm updates
- Technical SEO issues (like crawl errors or mobile usability)
- Content quality decline or duplicate content
- Poor internal linking or site structure
- Manual penalties for guideline violations
In short, correlation doesn’t always equal causation. Just because spammy backlinks appeared around the same time as your drop doesn’t mean they’re the culprit.
✅ What to Do If You Suspect Negative SEO
If you think your site is under attack:
- Stay calm and investigate
- Check Google Search Console for manual actions
- Analyze your backlink profile using trusted SEO tools
- Try reaching out to webmasters to remove bad links
- Use the Disavow Tool only if truly necessary
- Review your site’s technical SEO, content, and user experience
🎯 Final Thoughts
Negative SEO is a scary idea—but for most websites, it’s not the real cause of ranking drops. More often than not, algorithm changes, outdated content, or technical issues are the real problem.
That said, it’s always smart to stay vigilant. Monitor your site’s health, secure your platform, and focus on building high-quality content and backlinks.
Because when you do things the right way—your rankings may dip temporarily, but they’ll always bounce back stronger.
Leave a Reply